This was a remarkable week for autism science and publicity. In a stunning and rare reversal, medical journal The Lancet retracted the 1998 paper responsible for suggesting a link between autism and MMR vaccinations, incurring over a decade of acrimonious debate and frightened parents. Ironic then that this should be the week when HBO premieres their new feature film Temple Grandin, about the eponymous world-famous scientist. Dr. Grandin has written and spoken openly about her struggle with autism and how it’s colored her view of the world and influenced the science she studies. ScriptPhD.com is extraordinarily honored to extend a warm welcome to friend and fellow blogger Susan Etlinger, author of the autism spectrum blog The Family Room, to review the biopic and interview the project’s executive producer. For full content, please click “continue reading.”
I cringe a little every time a new movie about someone with autism is released. Its such a complicated and contentious topic, even more so because autism is a spectrum condition which can manifest in a dizzying number of ways. Like snowflakes, no two people with autism are alike.
Consider that Dustin Hoffmans Rain Manthe obsessive, lovable card-counting savantstill remains many peoples icon of autism. Now consider that Kim Peek, the man who inspired the Rain Man character, was misdiagnosed as a child and wasnt actually autistic at all.
And while films about autistic people usually focus on the experience of the people around them, it is a much more courageous task to convey the point of view of the autistic person himself or herself.
All of this makes the subject of Temple Grandinauthor, internationally-known animal scientist, inventor and autism advocateeven more daunting. Her groundbreaking memoirs, including Emergence: Labeled Autistic and Thinking in Pictures, are generally agreed to have revolutionized our understanding of autism and the capabilities of people on the spectrum. So I approached HBOs biopic, Temple Grandin, starring Claire Danes in the eponymous role, with a mixture of anticipation and dread.
The choices made by producer Emily Gerson Saines, director Mick Jackson and Danes herself are impeccable. Gerson Saines, herself the mother of a boy on the spectrum and a cofounder of the Autism Coalition for Research and Educaion (ACRE), which is now part of Autism Speaks, says that she had the script vetted by multiple people, Dr. Grandin included, to weed out even the remotest speck of inauthenticity. There were a lot of eyes watching this script to make sure it was honest, she told me in an interview for ScriptPhD.com earlier this week. I was not going to mess it up.
Diagnosed as a child with autism and infantile schizophrenia, (a label that has since been discredited), Temple Grandin was raised by her mother Eustacia (Julia Ormond), who refused to institutionalize Temple despite the doctors urging and the conventional wisdom of the time.
Rather, Eustacia chose to home-school Temple, sending her to her aunts farm for breaks, and enrolled her in a boarding school where Temple met Dr. Carlock (David Strathairn), a science teacher who was the first to appreciate the unique qualities of Temples mind; namely, her ability to think visually (in pictures) rather than narratively (in words). This opened up a whole world for Temple, giving her confidence and ultimately enabling her to channel her empathy for animals into a career that would change the cattle industry and lead to her future as a speaker, author and advocate for people with autism.
But while there was pressure to be true to Grandins very particular story, there was also the question of whether parents of more severely-affected children would feel that Grandins many accomplishments would set unrealistic expectations. If you see a film about Michael Jordan, asks Gerson Saines, does that mean you then expect your son to become an NBA legend? The film is a point of departureit opens up the discussion.
The films specificityits refusal to generalize, sentimentalize or glamorizemakes it work. And what seems like a modest ambition, to tell the story of one very particular woman on one very particular place on the spectrum, turns out to be not only a thoughtful choice but a creatively rich one.
But what ultimately elevates Temple Grandin beyond the typical biopic into artistry is Danes fearless performance and the filmmakers commitment to communicating Grandins inner life. Its evident from the first frame, as she steps off a plane on the way to her aunts farm. The engines are so loud, the air so heavy, that you are immediately drawn into her world. That choiceto show the world from Temples point of view, with wit and with precisionis a gift to anyone who knows or loves a person with autism.
Ultimately, says Gerson Saines, the most important goal for her in making this film was for parents of children with autism to experience the renewed sense of hope and inspiration she felt when she encountered Temple Grandins work for the very first time, and to remember that with perseverance almost anything is possible.
Because, she says, Im one of those parents out thereand I need to be inspired.
Temple Grandin, starring Claire Danes, Julia Ormond, Catherine OHara and David Strathairn, will premiere on HBO on Saturday, February 6 at 8:00 p.m.
Susan Etlinger is the mother of a six-year-old son diagnosed on the autism spectrum and the author of the Family Room blog.
ScriptPhD.com covers science and technology in entertainment, media and advertising. Hire our consulting company for creative content development.